Compare

Element vs Mattermost

Both Element and Mattermost can connect to the Matrix network. The difference is how. Element Server Suite Pro is built on Matrix. Mattermost reaches it through a bridge plugin, with a separate Matrix homeserver you have to run yourself.

Digital sovereignty needs both open standard federation and interoperability: the freedom to talk to anyone, and the freedom to change any part of your own stack without being locked in. A bridge only gets you the first.

Feature

Element app

Element Server Suite Pro

Mattermost

Mattermost

Supports open standard federation

Supports Matrix open standard federation

Only via an add-on bridge plugin that also requires running your own Matrix homeserver

Minimum server deployment for Matrix-based federation

Synapse Pro is all that's required for Matrix-based federation

Mattermost, Matrix homeserver and "Matrix Connector" plugin are required for Matrix-based federation

Pick and mix backend components

Matrix APIs ensure backend components are swappable

Mattermost backend only, supports Mattermost plugins

Bring your own client

Matrix APIs decouple the client and server

Only Mattermost’s client can be used with the Mattermost server

Built on an open standard

ESS Pro is built on Matrix, an open standard implemented by many independent vendors.

Mattermost is its own platform; Matrix is only reachable through a bridge plugin.

Conversations are end-to-end encrypted

All communications are end-to-end encrypted by default

Communications are only encrypted-in-transit and at-rest

*As at November 2026

Federation is only half of interoperability

Interoperability has two parts, and digital sovereignty needs both.

{"core":{"label":"","show":false},"rings":[{"id":"r1","radius":60,"rotation":330,"connectToCore":false,"connectInRing":"full","animateConnections":true,"nodes":[{"id":"n1","label":"A","childRadius":60,"childRotation":0,"connectChildren":"mesh","shape":"server","children":[],"labelPosition":"above"},{"id":"n_3peebv","label":"B","shape":"server","labelPosition":"above"},{"id":"n_yzsim4","label":"C","shape":"server"}]}],"sizeMode":"aspect","padding":40,"aspectRatio":"4:3","boundsIncludeEnclosure":true} A B C

Open standard federation connects separate organisations, whichever vendor each one uses. Because ESS Pro speaks Matrix natively, it federates directly with any other Matrix deployment, whether built in-house or supplied by another Matrix vendor, with no bridge or second server in between. No single company owns the standard, so no one can fence the network off or decide who gets to join. Every organisation keeps its own platform, user experience and configuration, and still talks securely to everyone else on its own terms.

Mix and match server-side components on Matrix Three server-side layers sit on Matrix, the open standard. Integrations can have several vendors switched on at once; Homeserver takes one vendor, and Hosting is either self-hosted or hosted by a provider. The choices keep changing, and a line always connects them down to Matrix. {"id":"interop","title":"Mix and match server-side components on Matrix","desc":"Three server-side layers sit on Matrix, the open standard. Integrations can have several vendors switched on at once; Homeserver takes one vendor, and Hosting is either self-hosted or hosted by a provider. The choices keep changing, and a line always connects them down to Matrix.","layout":{"width":440,"controlWidth":196,"pad":20,"hold":4},"rows":[{"id":"frontend","label":"Frontend","control":"tabs","items":["circle","square","triangle"]},{"id":"features","label":"Features","control":"chips","items":["circle","square","triangle"]},{"id":"homeserver","label":"Homeserver","control":"tabs","items":["circle","square","triangle"]},{"id":"hosting","label":"Hosting","control":"tabs","items":["icon:building","icon:cloud"]},{"id":"openstandard","label":"Open standard","control":"mark","items":["logo:matrix"],"tint":true}],"states":[{"frontend":0,"features":[0,1],"homeserver":0,"hosting":0},{"frontend":1,"features":[0,1,2],"homeserver":2,"hosting":1},{"frontend":2,"features":[2],"homeserver":1,"hosting":0}]} Frontend Features Homeserver Hosting Open standard

Server-side interoperability is about what happens inside your own deployment. ESS Pro is built from components that connect through open standards, so you can easily mix and match. Connect your existing identity and access management, choose a different secure border gateway, plug in a third-party data retention module, move to another hosting provider, or develop features of your own. Components can come from Element, other vendors, open-source projects or your own team, and they work together because none of them depends on a private interface.

Element app

Element Server Suite Pro gives you a complete government-ready solution, but you can mix, match and extend as you see fit. You can also migrate comparatively easily to another Matrix vendor or an in-house solution, because sovereignty means keeping your options open.

Mattermost

Mattermost offers two types of federation: an Enterprise-gated, walled-garden Mattermost-to-Mattermost option, or a ‘Matrix Connector’ bridge that needs you to run a Matrix server anyway.

Mattermost’s "Matrix Connector" defeats the purpose

Mattermost's "Matrix Connector" plugin makes it sound like Matrix-based federation is a simple click or two away, but you need to install and manage a Matrix homeserver of your own in addition to managing Mattermost.

To get open standard Matrix federation out of Mattermost, you have to run a Matrix server regardless. Even with the "Matrix Connector" deployed, if your end-users connect to the Mattermost server directly, they are still stuck with the Mattermost client. The only way to achieve interoperability and be able to change clients is by using the Matrix homeserver directly. In other words, Federation means running a second server, and client choice means bypassing Mattermost entirely.

At this point, why not just use a native Matrix solution?

Mattermost’s Matrix Connector defeats the purpose Mattermost client, Mattermost server and the Matrix Connector plugin still need a Matrix homeserver of your own to reach Matrix federation. Any Matrix client can connect to that homeserver directly, bypassing Mattermost, which makes the Mattermost layers redundant. {"type":"grid","id":"mmconnector","title":"Mattermost’s Matrix Connector defeats the purpose","desc":"Mattermost client, Mattermost server and the Matrix Connector plugin still need a Matrix homeserver of your own to reach Matrix federation. Any Matrix client can connect to that homeserver directly, bypassing Mattermost, which makes the Mattermost layers redundant.","grid":{"cols":2,"rows":5,"cell":[190,60],"gap":[72,26],"pad":20},"hold":4.5,"items":[{"id":"group1","kind":"group","at":[2,1],"span":[1,2],"dashed":true,"fill":false,"label":"Matrix"},{"id":"mm","kind":"group","at":[1,1],"span":[1,3],"label":"Mattermost","dashed":true},{"id":"mmc","kind":"node","at":[1,1],"icon":"computer","label":"Client","labelPos":"left","parent":"mm","sub":"Mattermost"},{"id":"mms","kind":"node","at":[1,2],"icon":"server","label":"Server","labelPos":"left","parent":"mm","sub":"Mattermost"},{"id":"conn","kind":"node","at":[1,3],"icon":"plug","size":"sm","labelPos":"left","parent":"mm","label":"Connector","sub":"Mattermost"},{"id":"hs","kind":"node","at":[2,2],"icon":"server","label":"Server","labelPos":"right","tone":"accent","sub":"Matrix","parent":"group1"},{"id":"node1","kind":"node","at":[2,1],"icon":"computer","label":"Client","labelPos":"right","tone":"accent","sub":"Matrix","parent":"group1"},{"id":"node2","kind":"node","at":[2,3],"icon":"globe","label":"Matrix","labelPos":"right","sub":"Network","tone":"accent"}],"links":[{"id":"l1","from":"mmc","to":"mms","tone":"neutral"},{"id":"l3","from":"hs","to":"conn","fromSide":"left","toSide":"right","kind":"data"},{"id":"link1","from":"hs","to":"node1","kind":"data"},{"id":"link2","from":"conn","to":"mms","tone":"neutral"},{"id":"link3","from":"hs","to":"node2","kind":"data"}],"states":[{}]} Matrix Mattermost Client Mattermost Server Mattermost Connector Mattermost Server Matrix Client Matrix Matrix Network

Sovereignty requires interoperability and open standard federation

Federation gets you talking to other Matrix-based systems. It doesn't guarantee you can swap out a homeserver, replace a client, or walk away from a vendor whose roadmap no longer fits your needs. That's the difference between supporting an open standard and being built on one. Element Server Suite Pro is Matrix end-to-end; the client, server and everything in between - so that your organisation keeps genuine control over its entire communications stack.

Element Server Suite offers both interoperability and open standard federation by default, because Element is built directly on Matrix's open APIs. If you want the freedom to change vendors without losing the ability to talk to anyone, choose native Matrix.

Want to see what that looks like in practice?
Element Server Suite is the right place to start.

Matrix-native

Built on Matrix, the interoperable open standard: server, client and federation.

Supports Matrix federation

Non-Matrix server, but federates with other organisations over Matrix.

Bridged to Matrix

Vendor’s platform, only reaches Matrix through a bridge plugin.

Vendor-locked

A walled garden: one vendor controls the product, the network and your exit.

FAQ

Does Mattermost support Matrix?

Only with extra steps. Mattermost's Matrix Connector plugin makes it sound like Matrix-based federation is a click or two away, but you need to install and manage a Matrix homeserver of your own in addition to managing Mattermost. Even then, end users who connect to the Mattermost server are still stuck with the Mattermost client. Element is built on Matrix, so federation works natively.

Do I need a Matrix server for Mattermost to federate over Matrix?

Yes. The minimum Matrix-federated setup is Mattermost plus a Matrix homeserver plus the Matrix Connector plugin. With ESS Pro, Synapse Pro alone gives you Matrix federation.

Can I use a different client with Mattermost?

No. Only Mattermost's own client works with the Mattermost server. Element's Matrix APIs decouple client and server, so you can bring a different client without changing the whole stack.

Mattermost vs Element: which supports digital sovereignty?

Element. Sovereignty needs both open standard federation and interoperability. Mattermost's federation is a walled garden or a bridge, and its monolithic stack has to be replaced as a block if you switch vendors.

Be in your element.

Discuss how Mattermost compares to Element