Compare

Element vs Wire

All around the world, governments and defence organisations want communications infrastructure that's sovereign. That means being free from foreign jurisdiction and infrastructure, and not being reliant on a single vendor. Governments also need to talk securely with partner organisations, whatever platform those partners use.

Get the underlying architecture wrong, and that dependency becomes a liability; a change in a vendor's terms, its ownership, or the political landscape can cut off a critical channel overnight - at exactly the moment it's needed most.

Feature

Element app

Element Server Suite Pro

Wire logo

Wire

Digital sovereignty

ESS Pro and the Matrix open standard ensure users have autonomy over their solution and can switch to interoperable alternatives

Users can self-host but remain vendor-locked as Wire doesn’t interoperate with anything else

Freedom to switch vendor

Mix and match Matrix-based components, both server side and frontend apps, or move to another Matrix vendor entirely

Only works as a complete, single vendor Wire stack

Open standard stack

Built on Matrix, an open standard protocol that defines: messaging, federation, identity and encryption

Wire’s protocol is not an open standard

Protocol governance

Independent, stewarded by the non-profit Matrix.org Foundation

Set entirely by Wire

Supports open standard federation

The Matrix open standard for vendor-agnostic federation

Only supports Wire-to-Wire federation creating vendor-dependency

Federation control

Allow-listed federation with any other Matrix deployment, via any Matrix-based secure border gateway (such as ESS Pro's SBG, alternatives available)

Allow-listed, but only between Wire backends

Open standard encryption

Built on Matrix’s Olm and Megolm encryption protocols.

Uses an open standard (MLS) for encryption

Open source

End-to-end encrypted by default

E2EE by default, with the option to run unencrypted where the use case requires it

E2EE always on, with no unencrypted option

*As at November 2026

Owning and controlling your infrastructure

Real sovereignty isn’t about where a vendor is headquartered or where its servers sit. It’s about owning and controlling your infrastructure and having genuine choice over the technology you use: the freedom to run it yourself, switch vendors and interoperate on your own terms, without being dictated to by what allies or partners have deployed.

That only works with an open standard; a shared, published protocol any vendor can implement. Matrix is the decentralised open standard that makes genuine sovereignty possible, and Element is how governments and defence organisations put it into practice.

A traditional vendor-controlled stack, such as Wire, is the very opposite of digitally sovereign communications.

A Wire walled garden

Wire is European and open source. It can be self-hosted, and is end-to-end encrypted. As a traditional vendor-controlled walled garden environment, it’s also straightforward to implement if its one-size-fits-all design suits you.

But Wire falls short in delivering genuine digital sovereignty, because it’s not part of a competitive interoperable ecosystem. Its business model is still built on keeping customers dependent on a single vendor.

Schwarz Digits, the digital arm of Schwarz Group (owner of Lidl and Kaufland) is a principal shareholder in Wire. It is also the parent company behind STACKIT, the cloud platform it built to host ‘sovereign’ workloads.

Wire on STACKIT
means one group has a stake in both the infrastructure and the messaging app running on it. It mirrors the hyperscaler playbook, much as AWS runs Wickr as its own communications service. It’s convenient, but convenience isn’t control. Pricing, roadmap and exit terms all sit with the same commercial interests, and because Wire is a walled garden, there’s no open network to move to. European headquarters don’t remove the lock-in.

Matrix open standard
Connected across Matrix deployments Org 1 and Org 4 use Element. Four other organisations run independent Matrix deployments. The Matrix open standard lets organisations communicate across deployment boundaries. {"type":"grid","id":"element-matrix-ecosystem","title":"Connected across Matrix deployments","desc":"Org 1 and Org 4 use Element. Four other organisations run independent Matrix deployments. The Matrix open standard lets organisations communicate across deployment boundaries.","grid":{"cols":3,"rows":2,"cell":[64,64],"gap":[64,64],"pad":0},"wrapper":"frame","transition":0.5,"hold":4,"items":[{"id":"frame","kind":"group","shape":"none","at":[1,1],"span":[3,2],"pad":34,"frame":true,"clip":true},{"id":"group1","kind":"group","cornerRadius":20,"at":[1,1],"span":[1,2],"pad":16,"parent":"frame","clip":false,"cellOutline":"balanced","cellGapFill":50,"cellMode":"children","label":"Element","labelBackground":"none","shape":"cells","cells":[[1,1],[1,2]],"tone":"accent","labelPadding":4,"labelSize":9,"labelPos":"top"},{"id":"government","kind":"node","icon":"server","iconText":"W","at":[1,1],"size":"sm","style":"solid","labelPos":"above","label":"Org 1","parent":"group1","tone":"accent","labelSize":11},{"id":"supplier","kind":"node","icon":"server","iconText":"W","at":[1,2],"size":"sm","style":"solid","labelPos":"below","label":"Org 4","parent":"group1","tone":"accent","labelSize":11},{"id":"coalition","kind":"node","icon":"server","at":[2,2],"size":"sm","style":"solid","labelPos":"below","label":"Org 5","parent":"frame","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Fuchsia","light":"#671481","dark":"#e5b1e9"},"labelSize":11},{"id":"node1","kind":"node","icon":"server","at":[2,1],"size":"sm","style":"solid","labelPos":"above","label":"Org 2","parent":"frame","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Cyan","light":"#004077","dark":"#78d0dc"},"labelSize":11},{"id":"node2","kind":"node","icon":"server","at":[3,1],"size":"sm","style":"solid","labelPos":"above","label":"Org 3","parent":"frame","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Purple","light":"#4c05b5","dark":"#c4baff"},"labelSize":11},{"id":"node3","kind":"node","icon":"server","at":[3,2],"size":"sm","style":"solid","label":"Org 6","parent":"frame","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Orange","light":"#850000","dark":"#fbb37e"},"labelSize":11}],"links":[{"id":"link1","from":"coalition","to":"node2","routing":"direct","kind":"data"},{"id":"link2","from":"node3","to":"node1","routing":"direct","kind":"data"},{"id":"link3","from":"coalition","to":"node1","kind":"data"},{"id":"link4","from":"node2","to":"node3","kind":"data"},{"id":"link5","from":"coalition","to":"node3","kind":"data"},{"id":"link6","from":"node1","to":"node2","kind":"data"},{"id":"link7","from":"node1","to":"government","kind":"data"},{"id":"link8","from":"government","to":"supplier","kind":"data"},{"id":"link10","from":"supplier","to":"node1","routing":"direct","kind":"data"},{"id":"link12","from":"coalition","to":"supplier","kind":"data"},{"id":"link9","from":"government","to":"coalition","routing":"direct","kind":"data"}],"states":[{"duration":3,"hide":[]}]} Element Org 1 Org 4 Org 5 Org 2 Org 3 Org 6

Organisations 1 and 4 are using Element but can federate with other organisations that also use solutions based on the Matrix open standard.

Element is built on the decentralised Matrix open standard , meaning it can federate with any other Matrix-based deployment. This is perfect for intra- and inter-government communication.

Walled garden
Connected—if everyone uses Wire Government, Defence and Supplier use Wire and communicate inside its ecosystem. A coalition agency using another platform sits outside the boundary and would need Wire to join this federation. {"type":"grid","id":"wire-walled-garden","title":"Connected—if everyone uses Wire","desc":"Government, Defence and Supplier use Wire and communicate inside its ecosystem. A coalition agency using another platform sits outside the boundary and would need Wire to join this federation.","grid":{"cols":3,"rows":2,"cell":[64,64],"gap":[64,64],"pad":0},"wrapper":"frame","transition":0.5,"hold":4,"items":[{"id":"frame","kind":"group","shape":"none","at":[1,1],"span":[3,2],"pad":34,"clip":true,"frame":true},{"id":"wire-boundary","kind":"group","cornerRadius":20,"at":[1,1],"span":[1,2],"pad":16,"parent":"frame","clip":false,"cellOutline":"balanced","cellGapFill":50,"cellMode":"children","label":"Wire","labelBackground":"none","shape":"cells","cells":[[1,1],[1,2]],"labelSize":9},{"id":"government","kind":"node","icon":"server","iconText":"W","at":[1,1],"labelPos":"above","parent":"wire-boundary","size":"sm","label":"Org 1","style":"solid","labelSize":11},{"id":"supplier","kind":"node","icon":"server","iconText":"W","at":[1,2],"size":"sm","style":"solid","labelPos":"below","parent":"wire-boundary","label":"Org 4","labelSize":11},{"id":"coalition","kind":"node","icon":"server","at":[2,2],"size":"sm","style":"solid","labelPos":"below","parent":"frame","label":"Org 5","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Fuchsia","light":"#671481","dark":"#e5b1e9"},"labelSize":11},{"id":"node1","kind":"node","at":[2,1],"parent":"frame","icon":"server","label":"Org 2","style":"solid","size":"sm","labelPos":"above","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Cyan","light":"#004077","dark":"#78d0dc"},"labelSize":11,"labelBackground":"soft"},{"id":"node2","kind":"node","at":[3,1],"parent":"frame","icon":"server","label":"Org 3","style":"solid","size":"sm","labelPos":"above","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Purple","light":"#4c05b5","dark":"#c4baff"},"labelSize":11},{"id":"node3","kind":"node","at":[3,2],"parent":"frame","icon":"server","label":"Org 6","size":"sm","style":"solid","tone":"accent","colour":{"palette":"Orange","light":"#850000","dark":"#fbb37e"},"labelSize":11}],"links":[{"id":"government-supplier","from":"government","to":"supplier","fromSide":"bottom","toSide":"top","tone":"neutral","kind":"data"}],"states":[{"duration":3,"hide":[]}]} Wire Org 1 Org 4 Org 5 Org 2 Org 3 Org 6

Organisations 1 and 4 are using Wire which, being a walled garden, stops them federating with other organisations that do not also use Wire.

Wire is a walled garden that can only federate with other Wire deployments, severely restricting real time communications across governments.

No sovereignty without an open standard

Sovereign communications needs an interoperable open standard across the server side, the frontend and federation. The Matrix open standard is already used by more than 35 governments worldwide, it is independently governed by The Matrix.org Foundation. The competitive Matrix ecosystem includes more than 70 providers.

Without an open standard there is only a choice on which single vendor to depend on.

“Digital sovereignty means having choices, so no single technology and provider become a dependency that can be used against our interests.”

Karsten Wildberger
Federal minister for Bundesministerium für Digitales und Staatsmodernisierung

Matrix-native

Built on Matrix, the interoperable open standard: server, client and federation.

Supports Matrix federation

Non-Matrix server, but federates with other organisations over Matrix.

Bridged to Matrix

Vendor’s platform, only reaches Matrix through a bridge plugin.

Vendor-locked

A walled garden: one vendor controls the product, the network and your exit.

FAQ

Is Wire open source?

Yes, both are. Element has 35K+ GitHub stars and Wire around 10K. The difference is the protocol: Wire uses an open standard (MLS) only for encryption, while its messaging and federation protocols are its own. Element is built on Matrix, an open standard that defines the whole protocol: messaging, federation, identity and encryption.

Can Element federate with Wire?

No. Wire is a walled garden that can only federate with other Wire deployments, severely restricting real time communications across governments. Element can federate with any Matrix deployment, whether developed in-house or from a range of competitive vendors.

How is Wire federation different from Matrix federation?

Wire federation is moderated by Wire's design, inside Wire's own implementation, and only connects Wire to Wire. Matrix federation is open: any Matrix deployment can connect to any other, with allow-listed control via any Matrix-based Secure Border Gateway. Matrix is stewarded by the non-profit Matrix.org Foundation; Wire's protocol is set entirely by Wire.

Is Element a sovereign alternative to Wire?

Yes. Wire is European, open source and can be self-hosted, but it's a walled garden: nothing else interoperates with it, so you stay dependent on one vendor. Element is built on the Matrix open standard, so you can run your own infrastructure, swap components or vendors, and still talk to anyone on Matrix.

Who owns Wire?

Schwarz Digits, the digital arm of Schwarz Group (owner of Lidl and Kaufland), is a principal shareholder in Wire. It also runs STACKIT, the cloud platform Wire can be hosted on. So one group has a stake in both the infrastructure and the messaging app running on it, which concentrates pricing, roadmap and exit terms with the same commercial interests.

Be in your element.

Discuss how Wire compares to Element