Compare

Element vs Slack

Slack is deeply embedded in how many teams already work. If digital sovereignty, end-to-end encryption and network resilience are not important to you, it's a reasonable choice.

Government and defence organisations have to prioritise digital sovereignty. The diplomatic assumptions of the last few decades, during which SaaS became commonplace, are no longer safe to build on. No government can now risk handing a third party the power to cut off its communications, for any reason, at any time.

Feature

Element app

Element Server Suite Pro

Slack Logo

Slack

Offers digital sovereignty

Built on a decentralised open standard, with a range of hosting options and backed by a competitive ecosystem

Proprietary, vendor-controlled SaaS

Open standard

Built on Matrix, an open standard, implemented by many independent vendors

Proprietary; not published as a standard others can implement

Supports open standard federation

Enables native connections with any other organisation using a Matrix-based product

Only federates with other Slack workspaces, via Slack Connect

End-to-end encryption

On by default for 1:1 and group chats and calls, built on Matrix’s Olm and Megolm encryption protocols.

Customer-managed keys are not end-to-end encryption. Slack has explicitly stated it has no plans to offer end-to-end encryption

Resilient communications

Element’s decentralised design protects against global outages

Centralised architecture; Slack has had recurring multi-hour global outages

Protection against deplatforming

Can be self-hosted

Cloud-only; the service can be withdrawn or restricted without the customer's consent

Data control

You hold and control your data

Held in Slack's cloud (owned by Salesforce), under its terms

Jurisdictional exposure

Data stays under your organisation's jurisdiction

Slack can be compelled to disclose data under US law regardless of where the data is hosted

Freedom to switch vendor

Mix and match Matrix-based components, both server side and frontend apps, or move to another Matrix vendor entirely

Only works as a complete, single-vendor Salesforce stack

Air-gapped environment

Can be deployed for air-gapped environments

No air-gapped or on-premise deployment option

Familiar interface

Familiar WhatsApp-style interface, and combines the best of collaboration, messaging and VoIP

Usually the familiar incumbent, Slack is often favoured by change-resistant end-users

Integrations

Integrates with key enterprise tools, and Matrix APIs let you build or host your own integrations on your own infrastructure

One of the largest app ecosystems available, with thousands of ready-made integrations and workflow automation

*As at November 2026

Cloud dependency without interoperability

Slack is now owned by Salesforce, and runs exclusively on Salesforce-controlled cloud infrastructure. It is compelled under the US CLOUD Act to disclose data regardless of where that data is physically hosted. Like any cloud-only SaaS product, a government's access to its own communications depends entirely on one company's goodwill and continued uptime.

When it comes to governments and defence organisations working together, Slack also has no answer to interoperability beyond its own walls. Slack Connect lets Slack organisations share channels with other organisations using Slack, but if a partner or coalition agency isn't on Slack, they have to join Slack’s cloud to talk to you.

Slack Cloud
Cloud dependency without interoperability Slack organisations all live inside Salesforce’s cloud and can share channels with each other through Slack Connect. A partner agency that isn’t on Slack has no channel to share. {"type":"grid","id":"slackcloud","title":"Cloud dependency without interoperability","desc":"Slack organisations all live inside Salesforce’s cloud and can share channels with each other through Slack Connect. A partner agency that isn’t on Slack has no channel to share.","grid":{"cols":4,"rows":2,"cell":[64,64],"gap":[16,16],"pad":24},"hold":4,"items":[{"id":"group1","kind":"group","at":[1,1],"span":[4,2],"clip":true,"pad":20,"shape":"none"},{"id":"sf","kind":"group","at":[1,2],"shape":"none","pad":4,"span":[3,1],"parent":"group1","offset":[-32,-14],"fill":false},{"id":"c","kind":"node","at":[2,2],"icon":"org","size":"sm","label":"B","labelPos":"below","parent":"cloud1"},{"id":"partner","kind":"node","at":[4,2],"icon":"org","size":"sm","tone":"accent","label":"C","labelPos":"above","style":"solid","sub":"Not on Slack","colour":{"palette":"Fuchsia","light":"#671481","dark":"#e5b1e9"},"labelBackground":"none"},{"id":"node1","kind":"node","at":[1,2],"icon":"org","size":"sm","label":"A","labelPos":"below","parent":"cloud1"},{"id":"cloud1","kind":"group","shape":"cloud","at":[1,2],"span":[3,1],"parent":"sf","pad":4,"offset":[-32,12],"tone":"accent"}],"links":[{"id":"nochan","from":"c","to":"partner","tone":"neutral","labelBackground":"solid","dashed":true,"labelType":"both","labelIcon":"cross","labelIconSize":10,"labelSize":8,"labelBox":"outside","labelLayout":"below","colour":{"palette":"Pink","light":"#7e0642","dark":"#ffabbe"}},{"id":"link1","from":"c","to":"node1"}],"states":[{"labelOn":["partner"],"duration":3},{"labelOn":["partner"],"duration":3,"hide":["nochan"]}],"wrapper":"group1","transition":0.6} B C Not on Slack A

Slack is the opposite of sovereignty

Slack is convenient. That convenience is the whole pitch, and it comes at a real cost: your organisation's communication infrastructure depends entirely on one vendor.

None of this makes Slack a bad product for what it's designed to do. It makes it a bad fit for any organisation that needs to prove it isn't dependent on a single vendor, or that needs to reliably reach partners outside its own ecosystem.

Siloed communication

Slack Connect lets you bring people from other organisations into a shared channel or DM, but only if they're on Slack too. If a ministry, an agency, or a partner you need to reach isn't running Slack, you need to find another way to communicate with them. That's not interoperability. It's a walled garden with a visitors' entrance, and it's a strange position for a tool that started life as a bottom-up favourite precisely because it made communication easier, not harder.

Data lock-in

Your conversations, files and metadata live in Salesforce's cloud, in Salesforce's formats, under Salesforce's terms. Getting your data out, or moving to a different provider, isn't a configuration change, it's a migration project.

‍

Loss of control

Even with data residency, your data sits with a US company that can be compelled to hand it over. Salesforce is a US company, which means US authorities can request access to data under US law, wherever in the world that data happens to sit.

Vendor dependence

Because Slack Connect doesn't follow an open standard, and because you can only replace the whole stack at once, switching away means abandoning your platform entirely, not swapping out one component.

Sovereignty without complexity

Element Server Suite Pro runs on your own premises or hosted by a partner of your choice, and is supported directly by the people who build the software.

Because it's built on Matrix, it comes with open standard federation and full interoperability out of the box. You can talk to any other Matrix-based organisation, mix components from different vendors if you need to, and never find yourself locked into a single supplier's roadmap.

Reach out to us to start your sovereign journey .

Matrix-native

Built on Matrix, the interoperable open standard: server, client and federation.

Supports Matrix federation

Non-Matrix server, but federates with other organisations over Matrix.

Bridged to Matrix

Vendor’s platform, only reaches Matrix through a bridge plugin.

Vendor-locked

A walled garden: one vendor controls the product, the network and your exit.

FAQ

Is Element a self-hosted alternative to Slack?

Yes. Element Server Suite Pro runs on your own premises, managed by your own team, and is supported directly by the people who build the software. Slack is cloud-only and runs exclusively on Salesforce-controlled infrastructure, so the service can be withdrawn or restricted without the customer's consent.

Can Element connect with organisations that use Slack?

Not through Slack Connect. Slack Connect only lets Slack organisations share channels with other organisations using Slack, so if a partner or coalition agency isn't on Slack, they have to join Slack’s cloud to talk to you.

Element supports open standard federation, enabling native connections with any other organisation using a Matrix-based product.

Is Element end-to-end encrypted, unlike Slack?

Yes, Element's E2EE is on by default for 1:1 and group chats and calls, built on Matrix’s Olm and Megolm encryption protocols.

Slack offers no end-to-end encryption and has stated it has no plans to.

Can Element run in an air-gapped environment?

Yes. Element can be deployed in air-gapped environments. Slack has no air-gapped or on-premise deployment option.

Be in your element.

Discuss how Slack compares to Element